What is gained or lost by the film version being shot in 3rd person point of view, instead of the Scout's 1st person point of view in the book?
A lot of important information was lost because the film version was shot in 3rd person point of view, instead of Scouts 1st person point of view. It was very hard to understand Scouts thoughts throughout the film. For example in the book, Scout explained how she wasn't happy with Jem acting so mature. When Jem told Scout he didn't want to play the childish games anymore, because he was too old, the book went I to detail about how Scout felt about this. It was easy to tell that she wanted Jem to be less like Atticus and more like her. While in the movie, it was hard to recognize scouts perspective on the changes in Jem. Another example is when Scout meets Boo for the first time. In the book it goes into detail about Scout's emotions and thoughts when she sees boo for the first time. The book really goes into depth how she was amazed to see him and filled with joy. While in the movie it is difficult to understand exactly what Scout is thinking about Boo. Scouts perspective is harder to
understand because the movie is filmed from third person point of view.
Question 9
They say that the book is always better than the movie. Do you agree or disagree with this statement regarding To Kill a Mockingbird? Why or why not?
I do agree with this statement for this particular movie. The book has more detail included about the characters and events. Also it has more events that were important to the message and theme of the book. Certain scenes were left out in the movie that were important. For example, the fire scene was left out, where Boo put the blanket over Scouts shoulders. I think that this was really important to see how Boo had stepped out of his comfort zone for the first time, which was not in the movie. Another example, is that they didn't really elaborate much on the character Dill in the movie. Dill was an important part of scout and Jem's childhood and he was only in a couple of scenes. While, in the book Dill was very important to Scout and Jem and they always mentioned him, and were very eager to play with him. This was the only boy that they both really liked and got along with, but they never really made it clear of that in the film.
No comments:
Post a Comment