Thursday, October 16, 2014

Dialectical Journal


Megan Galvin

Mr. Beattie

English 1 Honors

10-16-14

Dialectical Journal

 

Q. 1.) “At left, a door leads to a bedroom which is shared by Mama and her daughter Beneatha. At right opposite, is a second room (which in the beginning of life of this apartment was probrably a breakfast room) which serves as a bedroom for Walter and his wife Ruth.” (24)

A. 1.) This house that they are living in must have been really small. Considering that one of the bedrooms was originally a breakfast room, people in the house must be very close together. the entire family must get sick of one another very easily considering that they are always near each other and can probrably hear just about everything that everyone in the house is saying. Where does Travis have to sleep? Is he treated differently because he is the youngest one? This family must be going through some sort of poverty.

Q. 2.) “Walter: I just wondered if you have made up your mind and everything. Beneatha: (Gaining sharpness and impatience) And what did I answer yesterday morning- and the day before that?”(36)

A. 2.) Walter is kind of a pest toward his sister as he always asks his sister the same question every day. This must be very important to him, being as insistent as he is that she does this. Beneatha obviously gets irritated very easily by him. She also is probrably not one to change her mind considering she is very stubborn about not doing what he wants. If Walter wants this so bad why doesn’t he just do it himself?

Q. 3.) “Travis: What’s the matter girl, you cracking up? Beneatha: Shut up. (She pulls the headdress off and looks at herself in the mirror and clutches at her hair again and squinches her eyes as if trying to imagine something.” (66)

A. 3.) This shows that everyone is noticing that Beneatha acts different around Asagai even her younger brother. Beneatha is stressing about her hair because she cares so much about what Asagai thinks. Since he made a little comment about it not being natural she is nervous now that it’s not good enough for him. If Asagai knew how much she cared for him how would he react? Does Asagai feel the same way about Beneatha?

Q. 4.) “Ruth (coming to him gently and misgiving, but coming to him) Honey, life don’t have to be like this. I mean sometimes people can do things so that things are better. You remember how we used to talk when Travis was born… about one way we were going to live… the kind of house… one is (stroking his head) well, it’s all starting to slip away from us (He turns her and they look at each other and kiss tenderly and hungrily, The door opens and mama enters- Walter breaks away and jumps up. A beat)” (89)

A. 4.) Ruth here is trying to be very comforting towards Walter by soothing him and telling him that it will be ok, because she knows he is stressed. She is trying to say that even though things aren’t going great they can just try to make the best of it. She’s also saying that he is losing hope and if they do then their dream will just slip away from them. I think Walter kisses her because he realizes how upset she is about their whole situation. Walter is also frustrated and I don’t think he wants to get into that conversation with Ruth so he breaks away. Walter is very stubborn on getting exactly what he wants and he doesn’t have time to ‘hope’ for his dream to come true so he avoids continuing his conversation with Ruth.

Q. 5.) “Ruth: (smiling to herself) we went to the movies. (Looking at Beneatha to see if she understands) we went to the movies. You know the last time me and Walter went to the movies together? Beneatha: no. Ruth: Me neither. That’s how long it’s been (smiling again) But we went last night. The picture wasn’t much good, but that didn’t seem to matter. We went- and we held hands.” (111)

A. 5.) Ruth is obviously overjoyed about them doing something as simple as going to the movies with her husband. She obviously missed spending time with him, the way that she talks about their time together. Ruth is every excited that they held hands which is rather unusual considering they are married. I think that it was something more than just holding hands. I think that it symbolizes happiness between the two of them. It also represents the first step towards a new beginning for the both of them.

Q. 6.) “Linder: Oh-yes. Thank you. (He slides the brief case and hat under the chair.) And as I was saying- I am from the Clybourne Park Improvement Association and we have had it brought to our attention at the last meeting that you people- or at least your mother- has bought a piece of residential property at- (he digs for the slip of paper again)- four o six Clybourne Street…” (114)

A. 6.) Linder thinks that they are different from them when he refers to them as “you people”. He is inferring that they are their own group segregated from the rest of the people at Clybourne Park. From this it isn't hard to tell that they are not wanted in the neighborhood. He quickly tries to cover it up because he wants to get his poi8nt across, but be as subtle as he can about it. He feels very awkward after saying this so he tries to distract them form that remark by looking for his papers.

Q. 7.) “ (Ruth stands stiffly and quietly in back of them, as though somehow she senses death, her eyes fixed on her husband) Bobo: (his frightened eyes on the floor, his hat in his hands) could I please get a drink of water before I tell you about it, Walter Lee?” (126)

A. 7.) This entire situation creates a very tense mood. Ruth is obviously sensing that something isn’t right. The way that she has “her eyes fixed on her husband.” Also the fact that Bobo is stalling by saying that he needs something to drink. He isn’t making eye contact because he doesn’t want to give anything away. This creates a very intense mood throughout this scene and suspects something must be wrong. Bobo is trying to distract himself because he doesn’t want to tell them something.

Q. 8.) “Mama: I seen … him… night after night… come in… and look at that rug… and then look at me… the red showing in his eyes… the veins moving in his head… I seen him grow thin and old before he was forty… working and working like somebody’s old horse… killing himself… and you- you give it all away all in a day-(she raises her arms to strike him again)” (128)

 

A. 8.) Mama here is talking about her husband who literally died working as hard as he possibly could. She explains how he died a hard worker. This money meant something more to her then wealth it was a gift from one of the people that she loved the most her husband. Mama is explaining to Walter how hard he worked to get all that money just for them. She is trying to tell him that he ruined the chance that they had of living a better life, the life that mams husband wanted them to live. To her the money being gone means that they have failed in doing what Big Walter had wanted for their family. This is why she is so angry with Walter Lee.

Q. 9.) “Asagai: Gave it away? Beneatha: He made an investment! With a man even Travis wouldn’t have trusted with his most worn out marbles. Asagai: And it’s gone? Beneatha: Gone! Asagai: I’m very sorry… and you, now?” (132)

A. 9.) Beneatha shows how she really feels here about Walters decisions. She is basically saying that it was such a stupid decision, that even someone as young as Travis wouldn’t have followed through with it. Also, I think that this shows how much Asagai cares about Beneatha. He doesn’t care one bit that their family doesn’t have all of that money, he just wants to know about her. I think that this displays his character traits very clearly because of how much he shows that he cares for Beneatha.

Q. 10.) “(Rather quietly for him) that when it is all over-that you come home with me- Beneatha: (staring at him and crossing away with exasperation) oh- Asagai at this moment you decide to be romantic!” (136)

A. 10.) Beneatha doesn’t know what to say because she feels very pressured. She has a lot running through her mind right now. There whole family has just lost all hope that they had of starting a new life and now that Asagai has asked her this it’s just too much for her to handle. Also Beneatha is probrably thinking about what other people might think about her moving to Africa. Also, what is going to happen about her and George? I think that Beneatha wants to say yes to going with Asagai just the timing was not in her favor.

 

Monday, October 6, 2014

Dream Poem: Ruth's perspective

Hope

Sometimes hope is all a person can do
It is possible to hope for many things
Although, these things might not come true

To sail around the world
To fly up to the highest clouds
And to live in Buckingham Palace 
That is what I want to do 

Some desire money 
Some desire power 
All I want is hope from everyone 
So that they can realize it will be better

So tired of fighting 
And arguing everyday 
Everybody wants there own way

I try so hard to hope for the best
All I want is to take a break and rest
I have to keep hoping 
For this is what keeps me going 

Without hope 
I would be nothing