Would you want
to spend your summer reading a book that you don't like? The Impossible
Knife of Memory by Laurie Halse Anderson is a book about the hardships of
the main character Hayley Kincain. In the book she struggles to take care of
her father Andy, who is an alcoholic and drug attic. Andy suffers from Post-Traumatic
Stress, which already sets a mood for the story. Meanwhile Hayley is a
character who thinks of everything in a negative way. The Impossible Knife
of Memory is a book that should not be read by freshman because it's
depressing, confusing, and extremely hard to relate too.
Freshman
shouldn't read this book because it is very upsetting. The main character
Hayley says that everyone is considered either a zombie or a freak. She says,
"There are two kinds of people in this world, 1. Zombies and 2.Freaks"(3).
This shows that Hayley has a very negative outlook on the world and that she
thinks everyone is against her. In her perspective everybody is either out to
get her or could just care less about her. This proves that Hayley is sort of a
pessimist which makes the mood throughout the book sort of discouraging. Also
there are a lot of family issues throughout the book which makes it very sad.
For example, Gracie's parents go through a divorce. To cope with this problem
Gracie decides to take drugs instead of getting real help. This is obviously not
the solution but unfortunately, it’s the decision that she makes. She says, “it's
okay they are legal. It’s one of my mom’s prescriptions” when she was offering
Hayley a ‘mint’ (151). This proves the point that since Gracie has family
problems it changes her whole attitude toward life. It clearly shows that
because of her family problems at home she is depressed which effects the mood
of the book. In the book the Impossible Knife of Memory by Laurie Halse
Anderson there is a gloomy mood because of family issues and the attitude of
some of the characters, which makes the book unpleasant to read.
Another reason this book should not be
recommended to read for high school is because it is very confusing. Some of
the chapters had all writings in italics like in chapter 20. It says in
italics, “I hitch a ride to the outpost
in a truck filled with ammunition” (61). It was tough to understand what it
really was about. It was also hard to understand who’s perspective it was from
considering both her and her father had lived in the lifestyle of ‘hitching
rides’. There wasn't anything that hinted what exactly she was writing about
either. This made it very hard to understand these types of chapters and it
threw you off track a little bit. These
parts made it difficult to comprehend what was happening or what she was trying
to say to her audience. Also in the book after Hayley said something or did
something she would say things like "action" or "asses".
For example it says, “Then Brendan came for me. Action” (271). This made the book confusing because it was hard to
tell what she meant by that and it wasn't very self-explanatory. These words
made no sense at all to the text. As you can see, there were certain things in
the book which made it very hard to follow and upcoming freshman would not be
able to handle this confusion.
The last reason that you shouldn't read this
book is because it is very hard to relate too. Hayley is in a situation where
she lives with her dad on a RV for most of her life and then has to move into a
new high school for the last year. For example Andy says, “let’s try to live a
normal life” (5). This proves that their unique ways of living were beyond
normal, which makes it difficult to connect to their lifestyle. Most everyone these
days starts and finishes school when you’re supposed to so it was unusual to do
anything differently. Also Hayley's character was also very hard to connect to.
She thought of everything in a negative way and acted like she could never be happy
and enjoy the good things that came to her. She says, “everyone is a born freak”
(3). This made her very unappealing and difficult to make connections to. She
is calling people that she doesn’t even know a ‘freak’. This proves that she is
an odd character, which makes it tough to relate to her. The book overall was
very hard to make connections too because of the characters themselves, and their
lifestyles. These factors made the book not enjoyable to read.
The Impossible
Knife of Memory by Laurie Halse Anderson is one of the worst books in the
history of writing. This is because of its unusual events that are difficult to
connect to in the everyday world, it was very confusing and hard to follow and
it’s dark and depressing theme. Although this book might have a somewhat
interesting plot, the majority of the book was hard to keep reading because it
was so bad. Readers would not at all be impressed with this book because of
several things that make it painful to read. This book should not be read by
the upcoming freshman because it is torture to have to spend your summer
reading this book.
No comments:
Post a Comment